Operations

Hamas operates from hospitals, mosques, using Gaza civilians as human shields

2023-10-31

Multiple reports say Hamas locates its military infrastructure, such as headquarters, bases, armories, access routes, and weapons factories, within or in proximity to civilian areas.

Share this article

Women and children from displaced families take shelter at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City on October 25, amid the ongoing battles between Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas. [Dawood Nemer/AFP]
Women and children from displaced families take shelter at Al-Shifa hospital in Gaza City on October 25, amid the ongoing battles between Israel and the Palestinian militant group Hamas. [Dawood Nemer/AFP]

The Palestinian militant group Hamas is again using civilians as human shields as it launches attacks from or near hospitals and mosques in Gaza, as it has done in conflicts with Israel since 2007.

The latest war between Israel and Hamas was set in motion on October 7, when Hamas gunmen attacked Israel from Gaza by land, sea and air, killing 1,400 people, mostly civilians, and kidnapping more than 200.

As Israel retaliates against Hamas in an aerial and ground assault, the Iran-backed militant group has faced criticism for its use of protected structures -- such as hospitals, mosques and schools -- to hide weapons and launch attacks.

Using civilians as human shields is a war crime, according to the International Criminal Court.

Israel Defense Forces on October 27 released a detailed map of al-Shifa hospital in Gaza, outlining several underground complexes and control centers it says are used by Hamas. [IDF]
Israel Defense Forces on October 27 released a detailed map of al-Shifa hospital in Gaza, outlining several underground complexes and control centers it says are used by Hamas. [IDF]

Hamas has been placing civilians in harm's way by firing rockets, artillery and mortars from or in proximity to heavily populated areas, according to a report by the Latvia-based NATO Strategic Communications Centre of Excellence.

The militant group also locates its military or security-related infrastructure, such as headquarters, bases, armories, access routes, weapons factories or defensive positions, within or in proximity to civilian areas, the report says.

It uses civilians for intelligence gathering operations, and battles Israel Defence Forces (IDF) from residential or commercial areas, the report adds, noting that "by engaging in these acts, Hamas employs a win-win scenario."

"If the IDF uses lethal force and causes an increase in civilian casualties, Hamas can ... accuse Israel of committing war crimes, which could result in the imposition of a wide array of sanctions," it said.

"Alternatively, if the IDF limits its use of military force in Gaza to avoid collateral damage, Hamas will be less susceptible to Israeli attacks, and thereby able to protect its assets while continuing to fight."

Military use of hospitals, mosques

Al-Shifa, the largest hospital in Gaza, conceals underground command centers for Hamas, the Israeli military said at a Friday (October 27) news conference.

Israeli military chief spokesman Rear Adm. Daniel Hagari showed a map of the hospital marking what the IDF says are generators, depots, command and control centers, and several underground complexes used by Hamas.

"This is where they direct rocket attacks, command Hamas forces," he said.

In a news conference later Friday night, Hamas-run Gaza government media office head Salama Marouf denied the accusations.

A PBS documentary produced in 2006 shows Hamas fighters roaming the halls of al-Shifa, intimidating staff and denying access to parts of the hospital, the Foundation for Defence of Democracies reported October 23.

In 2007, Hamas fired at its rival Fatah from within the al-Shifa complex, according to Human Rights Watch.

And in 2008, the New York Times reported that Hamas was operating openly from within al-Shifa, where it murdered at least six patients it accused of collaborating with Israel.

Hamas leadership was located in a bunker under the hospital's burn ward, the newspaper reported in December 2008, while the group's fighters fired rockets from areas near the hospital in an effort to deter an Israeli response.

In 2009, the Meir Amit Intelligence and Terrorism Information Center (ITIC) detailed Hamas's use of mosques in the Gaza strip for military purposes.

"They are used to hide terrorist operatives, store weapons, as sites from which rockets and mortar shells are launched," it said.

During the 2014 war between Hamas and Israel, multiple independent media outlets reported on Hamas's use of al-Shifa and other civilian infrastructure, including mosques, in Gaza.

ITIC also cited Palestinian sources who said Hamas used al-Shifa's X-ray department as a jail and interrogation facility.

In 2015, Amnesty International cited evidence of Hamas torturing and killing prisoners in al-Shifa.

More than 60,000 Palestinian civilians are currently sheltering at al-Shifa.

By launching rockets from the hospital complex, Hamas is putting them at risk.

Do you like this article?


Captcha *

2024-02-12

Using civilians of any age or race as human shields must stop. No to war!

Reply
2024-02-12

Using civilians of all ages and genders as human shields must stop. War should not be waged

Reply

agreed!!

Reply

2023-11-22

This is a lie and you know quite well that it’s a lie. Find other ways to lie; you’re always exposed. How can you consider the Zionist occupation a state and cover its news? It’s nothing but filth placed at the heart of the Arab World. It was you who placed it there, and now you’re trying to make it shine. Do you want us to believe you? Just say it frankly that you want a war against Islam and Muslims, and you don’t care whether they’re civilians or mujahideen. The news is over. Why then do you call yourselves as being humanitarian?!

Reply
2023-11-09

Until when will these crimes and lies continue? In addition to be a liberation force, Hamas also believes in Islam. That religion has proven it is the only religion that abides by human rights, treaties and humanity. Israel is nothing but a big lie, exactly like Europe. Long live Palestine, free and Arab!

Reply
2023-11-09

Lies and defamation. This is the approach of children of Zion who come up with pretexts to justify their crimes. This is a cowardly act that gives only one explanation, which is the fear of Israeli of the Palestinian child. Damn you, but you've created thousands like Mohamed Deif! Now you'll have a taste of torture and hell!

Reply
2023-11-09

Hamas has the right to run its operations from any place. It's been facing an occupying, brutal and unjust entity for 75 years. That entity has been killing, destroying, building settlements and ignoring the international law.

Reply
2023-11-09

Lies and defamation

Reply
2023-11-08

[unintelligible] the fold of Israel

Reply
2023-11-06

You're disgusting, shameless liars. Your reports are fake, o, most despicable creatures on the face of earth!

Reply
2023-11-04

Your info is based on what the criminal colonising entity is saying; that entity allows itself and justifies to the world the shelling of hospitals, schools, commercial complexes and bakeries.

Reply